| Newsflash | ||
|---|---|---|
|
||
| Numbing the Pain: The Link Between Trauma,Posttraumatic Stress Disorder,and Substance Abuse |
| Feature Articles - Dual Diagnosis | |
| Thursday, 30 September 2004 | |
|
“The more I drink, the more I won’t feel anything. The pain is so bad you just want to die. There is no other way out. If you talk about it, it will hurt too much. So instead, keep it a secret. No one will know.” — A client1 This client lives a terrible but common truth: many survivors of trauma use drugs or alcohol to cope with their pain. Most women and many men in substance abuse treatment have a history of trauma, such as assault, child physical or sexual abuse, rape, natural disaster such as hurricane, car accident, military combat, or life-threatening illness (Najavits, Weiss, & Shaw, 1997). After experiencing a trauma, many people heal naturally over time. But about one-third develop posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (Kessler, Sonnega, Bromet, Hughes, & Nelson, 1995). PTSD means staying “stuck” in the trauma, unable to successfully cope and go on with normal life. The person with PTSD suffers a range of emotional problems that are described in detail in the DSM-IV (American Psychiatric Association, 1994), including intrusion (such images of the trauma that keep coming into mind through nightmares and flashbacks), avoidance (a wish to avoid reminders of the event), and arousal (intense negative reactions, both physical and psychological, when reminded of the event). Rates of current PTSD among clients in treatment for substance use disorder (SUD) range from 11 percent to 59 percent (Najavits et al., 2003; Najavits et al., 1997). Aside from numbers, the suffering associated with this dual diagnosis can be extreme, including heightened risk for additional co-occurring medical and mental health disorders, associated life problems (such as homelessness, HIV, poverty, suicidality, work and relationship problems), vulnerability to further trauma, and difficulties engaging in treatment (K. T. Brady, Killeen, Saladin, Dansky, & Becker, 1994; D. A. Hien, Nunes, Levin, & Fraser, 2000; Najavits, Gastfriend et al., 1998; Najavits et al., 1997; P. Ouimette & Brown, 2002; P. C. Ouimette, Finney, & Moos, 1999).
Assessment
Counseling models2
Models that have been empirically studied
Seeking Safety (SS). This is a present-focused therapy to help clients attain safety from both PTSD and SUD. The treatment is available as a book (Najavits, 2002) providing a clinician guide and client handouts. See also the Web site http://www.seekingsafety.org/. It was designed for group or individual format, females and males, and a variety of settings, and has been studied with both adults and adolescents. It offers 25 topics to address cognitive, behavioral, interpersonal, and case management domains: Introduction/ Concurrent Treatment of PTSD and Cocaine Dependence (CTPCD). This 16-session, twice weekly individual outpatient psychotherapy was designed for women and men with PTSD and cocaine dependence (Back, Dansky, Carroll, Foa, & Brady, 2001). With some modifications, CTPCD has been used in a variety of settings including inner-city community mental health centers (Coffey, Schumacher, Brimo, & Brady, in press). CTPCD combines imaginal and in vivo exposure therapy for PTSD plus elements of cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) for substance dependence (Carroll, 1998; Kadden et al., 1995; Monti, Kadden, Rohsenow, Cooney, & Abrams, 2002). To balance the needs of sobriety skill-building and trauma treatment, the first five sessions focus on coping skills for cocaine dependence. Session six makes the transition to use of exposure therapy, which begins in session seven, and is combined with a CBT topic for the treatment of substance abuse. One pilot study on CTPCD has been completed (K. Brady, Dansky, Back, Foa, & Caroll, 2001). Substance Dependence PTSD Therapy (SDPT). SDPT (Triffleman, Carroll, & Kellogg, 1999) is an integration of empirically validated treatment approaches for substance dependence (Carroll, 1998; Carroll, Rounsaville, & Keller, 1991) and trauma (Stress Innoculation Therapy and in vivo exposure). SDPT was designed for both genders and for clients with diverse trauma histories. It is a five-month, twice-weekly individual treatment with two phases. Phase I is “trauma-informed, addiction-focused treatment” and offers five modules derived largely from CBT for substance use (Carroll, 1998; Kadden et al., 1995; Monti et al., 2002): Introduction to SDPT, Coping with Craving and Drug Use Triggers, Relaxation Training, HIV Risk Behaviors, and Anger Awareness and Management. Phase II is a “trauma-focused, addictions-informed phase” to reduce PTSD symptoms while continuing attention to the addiction. The first part of Phase II is a modified version of Stress Innoculation Therapy (SIT) to teach coping skills and cognitive restructuring about trauma-related and other stressful stimuli. In preparation for the in vivo exposure, clients are taught strategies to address avoided situations, such as how to approach and confront them. During the second phase, SIT is combined with in vivo exposure in the form of a desensitization hierarchy. A pilot study is completed (Triffleman, 2000), and a randomized trial is under review (Triffleman, personal communication). Transcend. Transcend is a 12-week partial hospitalization treatment program for Vietnam veterans with PTSD and SUD (Donovan, Padin-Rivera, & Kowaliw, 2001). It consists of 10 hours per week of group treatment, mandatory attendance in a substance abuse rehabilitation program, and supplementary activities (e.g., volunteer community service). Six weeks focus on skills development, and six weeks on trauma processing, based on a combination of concepts derived from constructivist, existential, dynamic, cognitive-behavioral, and 12-step theory. A pilot study analyzed data on 46 male veterans who completed the Transcend program (Donovan et al., 2001).
Models with empirical results not yet available Addiction and Trauma Recovery Integration Model (ATRIUM) (Miller & Guidry, 2001). This 12-week model for individuals and groups integrates CBT and relational treatment to emphasize mind, body, and spiritual health. It provides psychoeducational, process, and expressive activities, including a focus on the body’s response to addiction and trauma, anxiety, sexuality, self-harm, depression, anger, physical ailments, sleep difficulties, relationships, and spiritual disconnection. Helping Women Recover: A Program for Treating Addiction (S.S. Covington, 1999; S. S. Covington, 2000). This treatment integrates theories of women’s psychological development, trauma, and addiction treatment to meet the needs of women with SUD. While designed for group modality in residential, outpatient, and inpatient settings, it can be adapted for individual format. It consists of 17 sessions within four modules that women in treatment identify as triggers for relapse: self, relationships, sexuality, and spirituality. The model is published as Helping Women Recover, a facilitator’s guide and A Woman’s Journal, a workbook. Versions are also available for incarcerated women. See the Web site www.stephaniecovington.com. Trauma Adaptive Recovery Group Education and Therapy (TARGET) (Ford, Kasimer, MacDonald, & Savill, 2000). This is a present-focused emotion/information processing and strengths-based approach to skills training for trauma survivors, and can be conducted in individual or group modalities. The goal is to understand how trauma changes the body and brain’s normal stress response into an extreme survival-based alarm response that can become PTSD, and to learn a seven-step approach to changing the PTSD alarm response into a less distressing and more adaptive response. TARGET addresses substance abuse and PTSD concurrently in every session, with a focus on addressing PTSD to simultaneously reduce SUD symptoms and prevent relapse. The specifics of clients’ traumas are not discussed during the program. Trauma-Relevant Relapse Prevention Training. This early model (Abueg & Fairbank, 1991; Abueg et al., 1994) was designed for inpatient veterans with PTSD and alcoholism. Based on developmental and social learning models, it offers a framework to understand what has happened, tools for effective coping, an arena to experience the discomfort of previous coping mechanisms, and practice new skills. It has three phases derived in part from the stages of change model (Prochaska et al., 1994). Phase 1 solidifies motivation for change through assessment, education, and interpersonal work. Phase 2 represents the action stage, and incorporates exposure-based therapy in a developmental framework to address trauma issues. Phase 3 emphasizes maintenance and generalization of learning via modified relapse prevention training. Although there has been mention of empirical study of this model (Ruzek, Polusny, & Abueg, 1998), no results have thus far been published. Treating Addicted Survivors of Trauma. This book (Evans & Sullivan, 1995) provides an integration of therapy and 12-step approaches to the treatment of substance abuse. It is designed for childhood abuse survivors who have SUD and is based on a medical view of substance abuse as illness. It assumes that clients will accept the 12-step approach, it uses the principle of “safety first” as the overall therapeutic strategy, and it has five stages to guide the selection of strategies to promote dual recovery. The stages include crisis, skill building, education, integration, and maintenance. TRIAD (Clark et al., February, 2003). This 16-week group model for women focuses on six goals: maintaining immediate safety, promoting skill building, maintaining recovery and preventing relapse, assisting women to build on their own strengths, building social supports and interpersonal effectiveness, and enhancing capacity to cope with distress. It derives in part from Dialectical Behavior Therapy (Linehan, 1993). Other models. Other models are described briefly but have not yet been manualized or empirically studied. These include: group therapy for PTSD and alcohol abuse (Meisler, 1999), a model for inpatient units (Bollerud, 1990), and a brief book (Trotter, 1992). Other models are available for trauma or PTSD, but were not specifically designed for SUD clients, such as Trauma Recovery and Empowerment (Harris, 1998), Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (Shapiro, 1995), and Exposure Therapy (Foa & Rothbaum, 1998).
General treatment themes Psychoeducation. Clients often have little knowledge of PTSD and its relation to SUD. It can be highly therapeutic to learn about them and how commonly they co-occur. Such psychoeducation can help clients attain a respectful awareness of their symptoms, rather than feeling “crazy, lazy or bad” (Najavits, 2002).
Coping skills. Clients with this dual diagnosis often have poor coping skills. They may not have seen positive coping in their family of origin, and may have diminished coping due to the impact of PTSD and SUD. Poor coping may include substance use, self-harm and suicidality, passivity (letting life just “happen”), and relationship problems such as power struggles. Thus, most treatments designed for this dual diagnosis place a strong emphasis on coping skills.
Multiple treatments. Because this dual diagnosis is complex, with many associated life problems (homelessness, poverty, medical problems, HIV risk, parenting issues, legal problems), the more modalities of treatment, the better. This may include 12-step groups, parent skills training, psychopharmacology, group therapy, day treatment, domestic violence counseling, etc.
A call for clinical innovation Lisa M. Najavits, PhD, is Director of the Trauma Research Program in the Alcohol and Drug Abuse Treatment Center of McLean Hospital (Belmont, MA) and Associate Professor in Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School (Boston). She is author of Seeking Safety: A Treatment Manual for PTSD and Substance Abuse and A Woman’s Addiction Workbook.
Footnotes This article is published in Counselor,The Magazine for Addiction Professionals, October 2004, v.5, n.5, pp. 12-17. |
|
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|




Victims of domestic violence don't always realize they have been traumatized. I'm glad to see help available for treatment.











